Beyond The Walls of An Intriguing NY Farmhouse Abandoned For Four Decades

The Carll’s History

This image shows Carll around the mid-1900s. The photo’s website says Carll’s sister and two brothers were police officers, and her daughter owned a factory that made men’s shoes.

The Carll family has a prosperous history on Long Island comprising ties to Sagitikos Manor, which transferred to the Thompson family of Setauket, then to the Gardiner family. At the same time, the Carlls went on to be distinguished fellows of neighborhoods in and around the Huntington region.